How to File an Insurance Complaint

Insurance is a contract between you and your insurance company, where you pay a premium in exchange for coverage and benefits. However, sometimes you may encounter problems or disputes with your insurer, such as delays, denials, or unfair settlements of your claims. In such cases, you have the right to file a complaint against your insurance company and seek a resolution.

Filing a complaint can help you get the compensation or service you deserve, as well as protect your rights and interests as a policyholder. It can also help the regulators and the public to monitor the performance and conduct of the insurance industry. However, filing a complaint can also be a complex and time-consuming process, depending on the nature and severity of your problem.

In this article, we will guide you through the steps and options you have to file an insurance complaint in an effective and efficient manner. We will also provide you with some tips and resources to help you prepare and present your complaint, as well as some examples and statistics to illustrate the common issues and outcomes of insurance complaints. By the end of this article, you will have a clear understanding of how to file an insurance complaint and what to expect from the process.

Step 1: Identify Your Problem and Gather Evidence

The first step to file an insurance complaint is to identify the exact nature and cause of your problem. You need to be clear about what went wrong, when it happened, who was involved, and how it affected you. You also need to gather all the relevant evidence and documentation to support your complaint, such as:

  • Your policy number and details
  • Your claim number and details
  • Any correspondence or communication with your insurer or its representatives
  • Any receipts, invoices, estimates, or bills related to your claim
  • Any medical reports, police reports, photos, or videos related to your claim
  • Any expert opinions or independent assessments related to your claim

You should organize your evidence in a chronological order and make copies of everything. You should also keep a record of all the dates, times, names, and contact details of the people you spoke to or wrote to regarding your problem.

Step 2: Contact Your Insurance Company

The next step is to contact your insurance company directly and try to resolve your problem with them. You can start by calling or emailing your insurance agent or broker, who may be able to assist you or refer you to the right person. You can also check your policy document or your insurer’s website for their complaints handling procedure and contact details.

When you contact your insurer, you should explain your problem clearly and calmly, and state what you want them to do to fix it. You should also provide them with all the evidence and documentation you have gathered in step 1. You should ask them to acknowledge your complaint in writing and give you a timeframe for their response.

Most insurance companies have an internal dispute resolution (IDR) process that aims to handle complaints fairly and promptly. According to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), insurers must respond to complaints within 15 business days if they have all the necessary information and no more than 45 days in any case . In the United States, insurers must respond within 15 days of receiving a complaint . In the United Kingdom, insurers must respond within eight weeks of receiving a complaint . You should check the specific rules and regulations that apply in your jurisdiction before contacting your insurer.

Step 3: Escalate Your Complaint

If you are not satisfied with your insurer’s response or if they fail to respond within the specified timeframe, you can escalate your complaint to a higher authority. You have several options for this step, depending on the type and severity of your problem. Some of the common options are:

  • Contacting a senior manager or an executive at your insurance company. You can find their names and contact details on your insurer’s website or annual report. You can write them a formal letter or email stating your problem and requesting their intervention.
  • Asking a third party such as an ombudsman, a mediator, or an arbitrator to help with your dispute. These are independent professionals who can review your case and facilitate a resolution between you and your insurer. They are usually faster, cheaper, and less adversarial than going to court. However, their decisions may not be legally binding or enforceable.
  • Filing a complaint with your state or national regulator or consumer protection agency. These are government bodies that oversee the insurance industry and ensure its compliance with the laws and regulations. They can investigate your complaint and take action against your insurer if they find any misconduct or breach of duty. They can also provide you with information and advice on your rights and options.
  • Filing a legal claim against your insurer in court. This is the last resort option if all other options fail or are not suitable for your case. You can sue your insurer for breach of contract, negligence, or bad faith, depending on the circumstances of your problem. You will need to hire a lawyer and follow the legal procedures and rules of evidence. This option can be costly, lengthy, and risky, as you may not win the case or recover your costs.

You should weigh the pros and cons of each option and choose the one that best suits your situation and goals. You should also check the eligibility criteria, time limits, fees, and procedures of each option before proceeding. You may need to obtain a letter of deadlock or final response from your insurer before you can escalate your complaint to some of the options above.

Step 4: Follow Up and Monitor Your Complaint

The final step is to follow up and monitor the progress and outcome of your complaint. You should keep in touch with the person or organization handling your complaint and provide them with any additional information or evidence they may request. You should also keep a record of all the communication and actions taken regarding your complaint.

You should expect to receive a resolution or a decision on your complaint within a reasonable period of time, depending on the option you chose in step 3. For example, according to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), most complaints are resolved within 60 days, while complex complaints may take up to 120 days . In the United States, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) reports that the average time to close a complaint is 40 days . In the United Kingdom, the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) states that most complaints are resolved within three months, while some may take up to six months or longer . You should check the expected timeframe for your chosen option before filing your complaint.

If you are happy with the resolution or decision on your complaint, you should accept it in writing and comply with any terms or conditions attached to it. If you are unhappy with the resolution or decision on your complaint, you may have the right to appeal or challenge it, depending on the option you chose in step 3. For example, if you filed a complaint with AFCA, FOS, or NAIC, you can ask for a review by a senior officer or a panel of experts if you disagree with their decision . If you filed a legal claim in court, you can appeal to a higher court if you have grounds to do so.

Tips and Resources for Filing an Insurance Complaint

To help you file an insurance complaint effectively and efficiently, here are some tips and resources that you may find useful:

    • Be prepared and organized. Before you file a complaint, make sure you have all the relevant information and evidence ready. Keep copies of everything and store them in a safe place. Use a diary or a spreadsheet to track the dates, times, names, and contact details of the people you spoke to or wrote to regarding your problem.
    • Be clear and concise. When you contact your insurer or any other party regarding your problem, explain your situation clearly and concisely. Avoid using emotional or abusive language. Focus on the facts and the evidence. State what you want them to do to resolve your problem and why.
    • Be persistent and patient. Filing a complaint can be a long and frustrating process. Don’t give up easily or settle for less than what you deserve. Follow up regularly and politely until you get a satisfactory response. Be prepared to negotiate and compromise if necessary.
    • Be realistic and reasonable. Filing a complaint does not guarantee that you will get what you want or that you will win your case. Be realistic about what you can expect from the process and what you can prove with your evidence. Be reasonable about what you are willing to accept as a resolution.
    • Seek help and advice. Filing a complaint can be complicated and confusing. You may need help and advice from experts or professionals who can guide you through the process and represent your interests. You can seek help and advice from various sources, such as:
      • Your insurance agent or broker
      • A lawyer or a legal aid service
      • A consumer advocate or a community organization
      • An insurance adviser or an insurance comparison website
      • A financial counsellor or a financial literacy website


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *